The seemingly perfect worlds of Sydney and Alex, high school sweethearts on the brink of graduation, come crashing down around them when they learn that Sydney is pregnant. They face separate journeys of self-discovery and loneliness as they try to rebuild their individual lives and shattered dreams.

Brotherly Love is the story of Beverly's failed romance with her Family Home Evening "Brother" Steve and her subsequent efforts to turn Dave, a wayward returned missionary with a smoking habit, into husband material.